The Prague Post - Will Twitter's 'poison pill' be too tough for Elon Musk to swallow?

EUR -
AED 4.261576
AFN 81.366302
ALL 97.993721
AMD 442.70133
ANG 2.076683
AOA 1064.089619
ARS 1359.405934
AUD 1.787132
AWG 2.091626
AZN 1.969937
BAM 1.956681
BBD 2.315433
BDT 140.25318
BGN 1.956857
BHD 0.437848
BIF 3415.123688
BMD 1.160403
BND 1.483162
BOB 7.952617
BRL 6.377228
BSD 1.146812
BTN 99.472381
BWP 15.507919
BYN 3.752842
BYR 22743.893394
BZD 2.303528
CAD 1.592096
CDF 3338.478806
CHF 0.942079
CLF 0.028678
CLP 1100.514617
CNY 8.331116
CNH 8.325814
COP 4739.084726
CRC 579.358486
CUC 1.160403
CUP 30.750672
CVE 110.315169
CZK 24.817883
DJF 204.211111
DKK 7.459707
DOP 68.110388
DZD 151.008771
EGP 58.800045
ERN 17.406041
ETB 154.440305
FJD 2.611835
FKP 0.86158
GBP 0.855751
GEL 3.15614
GGP 0.86158
GHS 11.811372
GIP 0.86158
GMD 82.957489
GNF 9935.432783
GTQ 8.823013
GYD 239.91911
HKD 9.109098
HNL 29.950363
HRK 7.534843
HTG 150.50872
HUF 402.845612
IDR 19003.045112
ILS 4.02611
IMP 0.86158
INR 99.955756
IQD 1502.270252
IRR 48881.965111
ISK 142.416091
JEP 0.86158
JMD 182.801559
JOD 0.822737
JPY 168.773577
KES 150.272318
KGS 101.434977
KHR 4596.793412
KMF 496.074564
KPW 1044.361993
KRW 1585.348032
KWD 0.354817
KYD 0.955626
KZT 598.967235
LAK 24739.037546
LBP 102748.95692
LKR 345.063953
LRD 229.352328
LSL 20.783073
LTL 3.426367
LVL 0.701916
LYD 6.244786
MAD 10.505077
MDL 19.70179
MGA 5098.274641
MKD 61.561405
MMK 2436.570069
MNT 4157.8323
MOP 9.272637
MRU 45.335227
MUR 53.100631
MVR 17.875971
MWK 1988.487182
MXN 22.120058
MYR 4.937566
MZN 74.219632
NAD 20.783073
NGN 1797.487311
NIO 42.198827
NOK 11.662343
NPR 159.156009
NZD 1.930672
OMR 0.446181
PAB 1.146722
PEN 4.129478
PGK 4.725108
PHP 66.032135
PKR 325.393577
PLN 4.273882
PYG 9153.083731
QAR 4.193607
RON 5.048802
RSD 117.252911
RUB 91.09669
RWF 1655.938812
SAR 4.354005
SBD 9.678256
SCR 16.56449
SDG 696.824819
SEK 11.110975
SGD 1.487723
SHP 0.911894
SLE 26.050531
SLL 24333.069177
SOS 655.392409
SRD 45.071168
STD 24017.993547
SVC 10.034477
SYP 15087.415911
SZL 20.77727
THB 38.013591
TJS 11.324252
TMT 4.06141
TND 3.400747
TOP 2.71778
TRY 46.034684
TTD 7.793477
TWD 34.290477
TZS 3127.285654
UAH 48.057941
UGX 4137.881813
USD 1.160403
UYU 46.880512
UZS 14331.517641
VES 120.225636
VND 30373.541306
VUV 139.140207
WST 3.201098
XAF 656.249792
XAG 0.032056
XAU 0.000346
XCD 3.136046
XDR 0.816164
XOF 656.249792
XPF 119.331742
YER 281.571546
ZAR 20.661315
ZMK 10445.010328
ZMW 26.644888
ZWL 373.649204
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Will Twitter's 'poison pill' be too tough for Elon Musk to swallow?
Will Twitter's 'poison pill' be too tough for Elon Musk to swallow? / Photo: Kirill KUDRYAVTSEV - AFP/File

Will Twitter's 'poison pill' be too tough for Elon Musk to swallow?

The so-called "poison pill" Twitter has proposed to use against Elon Musk's potential hostile takeover is a mechanism with a proven track record that could force the outspoken entrepreneur into negotiations.

Text size:

To halt a takeover, the board plans to activate the pill if the Tesla CEO comes to own more than 15 percent of Twitter.

He already holds 9.2 percent of the company, and said Thursday he has ready the $46.5 billion necessary to make an offer for the rest.

Such a "pill" would allow other Twitter shareholders to purchase shares at half price, increasing the amount of shares in circulation and weakening Musk's influence.

It would then be nearly impossible for him to take total control of the company without having to spend significantly more than he had originally planned.

"The dilution created by this defense has generally served its intended deterrence effect," explained Eric Wehrly, associate professor of finance at Western Washington University.

The "poison pill" was invented 40 years ago by business lawyer Martin Lipton to counteract a wave of hostile takeovers on Wall Street.

"It was the age of the corporate raiders," Lipton explained to the media site The Deal in 2011, from investors such as Carl Icahn to Kirk Kerkorian.

Quickly contested in court, the practice was declared legal for the first time in 1985 by the Delaware Supreme Court -- a tax friendly state where Twitter, although officially based in Californian, is incorporated.

"Delaware is the home to roughly half of publicly traded companies in the US and has fairly well established law regarding the implementation of poison pills," said Jon Karpoff, a finance professor at the University of Washington.

"Unless there's something unusual about Twitter's pill, which I would highly doubt... Musk would be unlikely to have a successful legal challenge," he said.

Boston College associate law professor Brian Quinn doesn't think the issue will even end up in court.

"Elon Musk has no case," he said.

- Negotiate and rally -

An alternative to acquiring the majority of the company would be for Musk to change the makeup of the board, according to Quinn, installing new members more in line with his vision for Twitter.

But the agenda for Twitter's next general meeting, on May 25, is already set, meaning Musk would have to wait until the next general meeting in 2023 to even bring it up.

And the board of directors can only be removed in batches, anyways.

Some members' terms are up this year, while others will remain in their position until 2023, 2024 or 2025.

Musk wouldn't be able to win over a majority of the board until at least 2024.

According to Quinn, "there's no record of an acquirer overcoming the pill by replacing the board through two successive elections."

"The only option for an acquirer is to negotiate with the board of directors," Quinn said, presumably by proposing an even higher offer, but without any guarantee of success.

And in the event of a negotiation, Musk wouldn't be able to count on the support of former Twitter head and co-founder Jack Dorsey, unless there is a quick resolution.

Dorsey, who has previously expressed affinity for the billionaire, announced after his resignation in November that he would not run for another term as director and would step down after this year's meeting.

In tandem with the official negotiations, Musk would have to start making his case to shareholders, according to Karpoff, a task which has already begun -- mainly by tweeting.

"And I think his personal popularity among a lot of people will help them in that," Karpoff said.

"I wouldn't be surprised if we even got a bunch of retail investors involved in struggling to acquire Twitter shares, and joining the attempt to pressure board members to strike a deal with Musk."

V.Nemec--TPP