The Prague Post - Justice at stake as generative AI enters the courtroom

EUR -
AED 4.298308
AFN 81.92842
ALL 98.084438
AMD 449.658082
ANG 2.094583
AOA 1073.261444
ARS 1468.279515
AUD 1.797333
AWG 2.106729
AZN 1.991668
BAM 1.950584
BBD 2.361684
BDT 142.702048
BGN 1.952874
BHD 0.441244
BIF 3442.161504
BMD 1.170405
BND 1.495414
BOB 8.082386
BRL 6.37672
BSD 1.169772
BTN 100.183093
BWP 15.616838
BYN 3.827896
BYR 22939.94066
BZD 2.349537
CAD 1.601886
CDF 3377.78954
CHF 0.933357
CLF 0.02875
CLP 1103.282348
CNY 8.396545
CNH 8.408618
COP 4742.04856
CRC 591.323751
CUC 1.170405
CUP 31.015736
CVE 110.718148
CZK 24.646426
DJF 208.0043
DKK 7.461362
DOP 70.350158
DZD 151.75855
EGP 58.145374
ERN 17.556077
ETB 159.672582
FJD 2.63493
FKP 0.862316
GBP 0.862764
GEL 3.171819
GGP 0.862316
GHS 12.166116
GIP 0.862316
GMD 83.688631
GNF 10131.027064
GTQ 8.990189
GYD 244.728101
HKD 9.187663
HNL 30.84028
HRK 7.530413
HTG 153.519463
HUF 400.091736
IDR 19027.510373
ILS 3.917797
IMP 0.862316
INR 100.486011
IQD 1533.230728
IRR 49303.316231
ISK 142.964601
JEP 0.862316
JMD 186.69553
JOD 0.829797
JPY 172.183562
KES 151.572338
KGS 102.35198
KHR 4706.199287
KMF 492.135958
KPW 1053.33889
KRW 1609.04963
KWD 0.357653
KYD 0.974835
KZT 607.784679
LAK 25222.230108
LBP 104868.299941
LKR 351.638671
LRD 234.666446
LSL 20.82134
LTL 3.455902
LVL 0.707966
LYD 6.317227
MAD 10.539461
MDL 19.797818
MGA 5184.89504
MKD 61.456221
MMK 2457.274227
MNT 4200.068068
MOP 9.458292
MRU 46.470981
MUR 52.797044
MVR 18.017904
MWK 2032.412478
MXN 21.795138
MYR 4.979492
MZN 74.859293
NAD 20.821752
NGN 1792.545747
NIO 43.012461
NOK 11.837998
NPR 160.294714
NZD 1.958001
OMR 0.450015
PAB 1.169682
PEN 4.148497
PGK 4.827984
PHP 66.236151
PKR 332.687497
PLN 4.243969
PYG 9322.309495
QAR 4.260981
RON 5.080258
RSD 117.17157
RUB 91.876031
RWF 1678.360965
SAR 4.389513
SBD 9.757579
SCR 16.795029
SDG 702.829472
SEK 11.168743
SGD 1.499763
SHP 0.919755
SLE 26.33756
SLL 24542.814783
SOS 668.884838
SRD 43.683615
STD 24225.023271
SVC 10.234892
SYP 15217.759559
SZL 20.821484
THB 38.256993
TJS 11.235231
TMT 4.108122
TND 3.388456
TOP 2.741205
TRY 46.869412
TTD 7.935846
TWD 34.069936
TZS 3090.09425
UAH 48.858496
UGX 4204.755761
USD 1.170405
UYU 46.96561
UZS 14893.405655
VES 131.422218
VND 30603.168287
VUV 139.633925
WST 3.222549
XAF 654.218686
XAG 0.032033
XAU 0.000356
XCD 3.163078
XDR 0.812997
XOF 651.915763
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.061714
ZAR 20.832029
ZMK 10535.048293
ZMW 28.335227
ZWL 376.869976
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Justice at stake as generative AI enters the courtroom
Justice at stake as generative AI enters the courtroom / Photo: Jefferson Siegel - POOL/AFP

Justice at stake as generative AI enters the courtroom

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is making its way into courts despite early stumbles, raising questions about how it will influence the legal system and justice itself.

Text size:

Judges use the technology for research, lawyers utilize it for appeals and parties involved in cases have relied on GenAI to help express themselves in court.

"It's probably used more than people expect," said Daniel Linna, a professor at the Northwestern Pritzker School of Law, about GenAI in the US legal system.

"Judges don't necessarily raise their hand and talk about this to a whole room of judges, but I have people who come to me afterward and say they are experimenting with it."

In one prominent instance, GenAI enabled murder victim Chris Pelkey to address an Arizona courtroom -- in the form of a video avatar -- at the sentencing of the man convicted of shooting him dead in 2021 during a clash between motorists.

"I believe in forgiveness," said a digital proxy of Pelkey created by his sister, Stacey Wales.

The judge voiced appreciation for the avatar, saying it seemed authentic.

"I knew it would be powerful," Wales told AFP, "that that it would humanize Chris in the eyes of the judge."

The AI testimony, a first of its kind, ended the sentencing hearing at which Wales and other members of the slain man's family spoke about the impact of the loss.

Since the hearing, examples of GenAI being used in US legal cases have multiplied.

"It is a helpful tool and it is time-saving, as long as the accuracy is confirmed," said attorney Stephen Schwartz, who practices in the northeastern state of Maine.

"Overall, it's a positive development in jurisprudence."

Schwartz described using ChatGPT as well as GenAI legal assistants, such as LexisNexis Protege and CoCounsel from Thomson Reuters, for researching case law and other tasks.

"You can't completely rely on it," Schwartz cautioned, recommending that cases proffered by GenAI be read to ensure accuracy.

"We are all aware of a horror story where AI comes up with mixed-up case things."

The technology has been the culprit behind false legal citations, far-fetched case precedents, and flat-out fabrications.

In early May, a federal judge in Los Angeles imposed $31,100 in fines and damages on two law firms for an error-riddled petition drafted with the help of GenAI, blasting it as a "collective debacle."

The tech is also being relied on by some who skip lawyers and represent themselves in court, often causing legal errors.

And as GenAI makes it easier and cheaper to draft legal complaints, courts already overburdened by caseloads could see them climb higher, said Shay Cleary of the National Center for State Courts.

"Courts need to be prepared to handle that," Cleary said.

- Transformation -

Law professor Linna sees the potential for GenAI to be part of the solution though, giving more people the ability to seek justice in courts made more efficient.

"We have a huge number of people who don't have access to legal services," Linna said.

"These tools can be transformative; of course we need to be thoughtful about how we integrate them."

Federal judges in the US capitol have written decisions noting their use of ChatGPT in laying out their opinions.

"Judges need to be technologically up-to-date and trained in AI," Linna said.

GenAI assistants already have the potential to influence the outcome of cases the same way a human law clerk might, reasoned the professor.

Facts or case law pointed out by GenAI might sway a judge's decision, and could be different than what a legal clerk would have come up with.

But if GenAI lives up to its potential and excels at finding the best information for judges to consider, that could make for well-grounded rulings less likely to be overturned on appeal, according to Linna.

L.Hajek--TPP