The Prague Post - Waste of tears -- fake 'onion water' flu cure exposes disparities

EUR -
AED 4.175963
AFN 81.859888
ALL 97.833883
AMD 442.794476
ANG 2.049103
AOA 1040.871097
ARS 1358.278539
AUD 1.751292
AWG 2.0465
AZN 1.923959
BAM 1.962903
BBD 2.295166
BDT 138.109778
BGN 1.954941
BHD 0.428568
BIF 3334.089038
BMD 1.136944
BND 1.466264
BOB 7.883772
BRL 6.497183
BSD 1.136744
BTN 95.889949
BWP 15.414254
BYN 3.720109
BYR 22284.107466
BZD 2.283433
CAD 1.566425
CDF 3264.167118
CHF 0.935254
CLF 0.027822
CLP 1067.636379
CNY 8.205384
CNH 8.19772
COP 4889.428784
CRC 575.096275
CUC 1.136944
CUP 30.129023
CVE 110.709978
CZK 24.959675
DJF 202.057769
DKK 7.462448
DOP 66.909402
DZD 150.787483
EGP 57.565583
ERN 17.054164
ETB 150.019742
FJD 2.558465
FKP 0.856011
GBP 0.850286
GEL 3.120933
GGP 0.856011
GHS 15.377203
GIP 0.856011
GMD 80.723722
GNF 9840.817061
GTQ 8.751014
GYD 237.827949
HKD 8.815007
HNL 29.450522
HRK 7.531106
HTG 148.573523
HUF 404.308687
IDR 18690.454054
ILS 4.097587
IMP 0.856011
INR 96.362905
IQD 1489.396979
IRR 47879.566356
ISK 146.847549
JEP 0.856011
JMD 180.128962
JOD 0.806321
JPY 161.94071
KES 147.236333
KGS 99.425844
KHR 4568.242123
KMF 492.896875
KPW 1023.230307
KRW 1564.184772
KWD 0.348382
KYD 0.947357
KZT 584.912054
LAK 24580.7349
LBP 101813.358561
LKR 340.455481
LRD 226.99096
LSL 20.688819
LTL 3.3571
LVL 0.687726
LYD 6.226779
MAD 10.501919
MDL 19.478085
MGA 5048.032913
MKD 61.543079
MMK 2387.207454
MNT 4064.457554
MOP 9.073714
MRU 44.980772
MUR 51.605601
MVR 17.520593
MWK 1973.735031
MXN 22.366343
MYR 4.812121
MZN 72.654794
NAD 20.695014
NGN 1826.609151
NIO 41.782666
NOK 11.672609
NPR 153.423241
NZD 1.892589
OMR 0.437715
PAB 1.136749
PEN 4.166241
PGK 4.624805
PHP 63.106108
PKR 319.770208
PLN 4.275649
PYG 9100.933534
QAR 4.139647
RON 5.091192
RSD 117.271295
RUB 92.633858
RWF 1614.190962
SAR 4.264691
SBD 9.502385
SCR 16.171319
SDG 682.73672
SEK 10.881353
SGD 1.464663
SHP 0.89346
SLE 25.842404
SLL 23841.134166
SOS 649.761061
SRD 41.896318
STD 23532.450669
SVC 9.945992
SYP 14782.494175
SZL 20.686668
THB 37.087079
TJS 11.793741
TMT 3.979305
TND 3.410376
TOP 2.662833
TRY 43.918457
TTD 7.704116
TWD 34.097523
TZS 3066.896111
UAH 47.098335
UGX 4158.046717
USD 1.136944
UYU 47.683391
UZS 14717.743617
VES 100.747393
VND 29519.052255
VUV 137.233359
WST 3.145092
XAF 658.365484
XAG 0.034225
XAU 0.000331
XCD 3.072649
XDR 0.820487
XOF 654.879759
XPF 119.331742
YER 277.983091
ZAR 20.689546
ZMK 10233.85814
ZMW 30.721116
ZWL 366.095587
  • RBGPF

    3.2400

    66.24

    +4.89%

  • CMSD

    0.0500

    22.31

    +0.22%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    22.06

    +0.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    13.05

    0%

  • BCE

    0.2000

    21.59

    +0.93%

  • BCC

    -4.9900

    87.48

    -5.7%

  • SCS

    -0.1000

    9.87

    -1.01%

  • NGG

    0.4600

    72.3

    +0.64%

  • RIO

    0.2300

    59.8

    +0.38%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    10.39

    -0.29%

  • RELX

    -0.1100

    54.93

    -0.2%

  • VOD

    0.0700

    9.67

    +0.72%

  • GSK

    -1.3500

    37.5

    -3.6%

  • BTI

    0.8100

    44.56

    +1.82%

  • AZN

    -1.8300

    70.26

    -2.6%

  • BP

    -0.7800

    28.4

    -2.75%

Waste of tears -- fake 'onion water' flu cure exposes disparities
Waste of tears -- fake 'onion water' flu cure exposes disparities / Photo: OLIVIER DOULIERY - AFP

Waste of tears -- fake 'onion water' flu cure exposes disparities

If it tastes this bad, it must be good for you?

Text size:

Homemade, tear-inducingly strong onion "cures" for flu are the latest medical misinformation spreading on TikTok -- a sign, analysts say, that affordable, evidence-based health care is beyond the reach of many Americans.

Videos extolling the pungent concoction –- made by soaking chopped raw onions in water –- as a miracle cure have garnered tens of millions of views on the influential app despite no scientific proof to support the claim.

The videos have gained traction as the United States faces a so-called "tripledemic" of influenza, Covid-19 and RSV that has put a strain on health services.

Onions in reasonable quantities are not considered harmful –- except for the foul breath –- but health experts warn that such videos promoted a blind belief in simple home remedies that could compromise public health.

"Onions aren't going to hurt anybody, but if somebody is sick, they should seek actual medical attention," Katrine Wallace, an epidemiologist and assistant professor at the University of Illinois Chicago, told AFP.

"I am afraid that people will just drink onions and not seek medical care (and) they could spread Covid or the flu in the community."

The pseudoscience has found many takers, with comments under the videos filled with declarations like "this worked for me!"

That, Wallace said, suggested the so-called "placebo effect," with the dubious onion treatment getting the credit after the virus naturally ran its course.

- Miracle cure? No -

The trend illustrates how TikTok is flooded with unqualified influencers who peddle misinformation, from vaccine and abortion-related falsehoods to health myths –- often to boost engagement and views -- in what experts say can have a serious impact on medical decisions.

In one of the most popular TikTok videos, which garnered over 2.5 million views, one woman -- whose profile did not mention her qualifications and described her only as a "child of mother nature" -- zealously promoted onion water.

For greater healing effects, she implored her viewers to ferment the concoction for hours to make it more "potent."

"We love a miracle cure and for some reason we seem to think that the more painful a remedy is to consume, the more magic it will work," Abbie Richards, a disinformation researcher and fellow with the Accelerationism Research Consortium, told AFP.

"Simple solutions for complex problems frequently perform well in engagement-driven algorithms like TikTok's. Particularly when those solutions are cheap and accessible in areas where evidence-based healthcare is not."

A TikTok spokesman told AFP the platform removes content that qualifies as medical misinformation that is "likely to cause significant harm."

The onion water videos, he added, did not cross that threshold of "significant harm" and were therefore left untouched.

- Millions without medical insurance -

That approach, many experts say, underscores the challenge facing social media platforms of finding ways to eliminate misinformation without giving users the impression that they were trampling on free speech.

Richards cautioned that "excessive moderation" in the case of onion water videos could backfire and "encourage narratives that the truth of affordable medicine is being intentionally hidden."

A more effective approach, she said, would be for TikTok to ensure accurate health information is "available, accessible, and engaging."

"Whether TikTok should take down videos about benign but useless remedies, that's not for me to say," Valerie Pavilonis, an analyst at the misinformation watchdog NewsGuard, told AFP.

"Still, even if a supposed remedy like drinking onion water to solve sinus problems doesn't directly hurt you, it could make you wrongly think that you are treating the problem."

The popularity of the videos reflected what Richards called "systemic failures" in health care.

In a country with expensive medical care, data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention shows roughly 30 million Americans, or nine percent of the population, have no health insurance.

Millions of other Americans are "underinsured", with their coverage not providing them affordable healthcare, according to the nonprofit Commonwealth Fund.

"It's very easy for us to say: 'Remember to talk to your doctor about medical treatments,'" Richards said.

"But I would expect that a society with limited access to health care, an overburdened health care system, and a generally confused approach to the newest wave in illness, might start drinking onion water or putting garlic in their ears."

M.Soucek--TPP