The Prague Post - Europe court says S.African athlete's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair

EUR -
AED 4.296862
AFN 80.13432
ALL 97.55034
AMD 448.921516
ANG 2.093605
AOA 1072.759497
ARS 1468.92409
AUD 1.77709
AWG 2.108669
AZN 1.991642
BAM 1.952068
BBD 2.363581
BDT 142.347822
BGN 1.957079
BHD 0.441028
BIF 3487.831052
BMD 1.169858
BND 1.497038
BOB 8.118477
BRL 6.471304
BSD 1.170562
BTN 100.245325
BWP 15.598175
BYN 3.830875
BYR 22929.219916
BZD 2.351404
CAD 1.598319
CDF 3376.210334
CHF 0.932301
CLF 0.028963
CLP 1111.434915
CNY 8.394085
CNH 8.397792
COP 4698.150366
CRC 590.371174
CUC 1.169858
CUP 31.001241
CVE 110.844287
CZK 24.637099
DJF 207.907527
DKK 7.460174
DOP 70.424632
DZD 152.102586
EGP 57.910979
ERN 17.547872
ETB 159.217577
FJD 2.620189
FKP 0.861206
GBP 0.861817
GEL 3.170527
GGP 0.861206
GHS 12.198185
GIP 0.861206
GMD 83.641127
GNF 10126.29191
GTQ 8.992805
GYD 244.911714
HKD 9.182744
HNL 30.826267
HRK 7.535757
HTG 153.586333
HUF 398.746258
IDR 18968.080189
ILS 3.880538
IMP 0.861206
INR 100.282288
IQD 1532.514188
IRR 49280.275111
ISK 142.792964
JEP 0.861206
JMD 187.072306
JOD 0.829436
JPY 171.08821
KES 151.495523
KGS 102.303613
KHR 4703.999644
KMF 492.510298
KPW 1052.860585
KRW 1604.729864
KWD 0.357637
KYD 0.975535
KZT 607.278845
LAK 25198.744658
LBP 104819.291214
LKR 351.647628
LRD 234.491657
LSL 20.811296
LTL 3.454287
LVL 0.707635
LYD 6.319015
MAD 10.52897
MDL 19.806129
MGA 5182.471634
MKD 61.537007
MMK 2456.177924
MNT 4196.053248
MOP 9.465202
MRU 46.477994
MUR 52.88898
MVR 18.018256
MWK 2031.45995
MXN 21.781821
MYR 4.968974
MZN 74.824198
NAD 20.811885
NGN 1790.929049
NIO 42.991905
NOK 11.792875
NPR 160.39232
NZD 1.939099
OMR 0.449808
PAB 1.170562
PEN 4.14656
PGK 4.840833
PHP 66.108362
PKR 332.826741
PLN 4.252142
PYG 9072.652528
QAR 4.258984
RON 5.07603
RSD 117.130907
RUB 86.627004
RWF 1677.5766
SAR 4.387431
SBD 9.753019
SCR 16.787763
SDG 702.506091
SEK 11.121491
SGD 1.497302
SHP 0.919325
SLE 26.322424
SLL 24531.344951
SOS 668.575785
SRD 43.715279
STD 24213.701956
SVC 10.242416
SYP 15210.414391
SZL 20.811767
THB 38.11152
TJS 11.325545
TMT 4.106202
TND 3.3984
TOP 2.739926
TRY 46.942195
TTD 7.948801
TWD 34.21039
TZS 3076.726899
UAH 48.99422
UGX 4194.978941
USD 1.169858
UYU 47.559064
UZS 14827.95222
VES 132.903253
VND 30550.260892
VUV 139.732377
WST 3.21827
XAF 654.705163
XAG 0.031615
XAU 0.000352
XCD 3.1616
XDR 0.813535
XOF 653.345202
XPF 119.331742
YER 282.930435
ZAR 20.75597
ZMK 10530.118441
ZMW 27.421568
ZWL 376.69385
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Europe court says S.African athlete's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair
Europe court says S.African athlete's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair / Photo: Phill Magakoe - AFP/File

Europe court says S.African athlete's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair

A top European court ruled Thursday that the Swiss judiciary did not give double Olympic champion Caster Semenya a fair trial when she contested a rule forcing her to lower her testosterone levels to be able to compete as a woman.

Text size:

However, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), in its final decision, said it could not determine whether or not the South African runner had suffered discrimination.

Its verdict comes after a row over the gender of an Algerian boxing champion engulfed the 2024 Paris Olympics, and as the International Olympic Committee mulls reintroducing contested gender testing.

Semenya, 34, is classed as having "differences in sexual development", but has always been legally identified as female.

She has been unable to compete in her favoured 800m category since 2018, after she refused to take drugs to reduce her testosterone levels under new rules from World Athletics, the governing body for track and field.

Semenya told journalists the ECHR's decision was a "positive outcome".

"We need to respect athletes, we need to put their rights first," said the athlete, who was Olympic 800m champion in 2012 and 2016 and world gold medallist in 2009, 2011 and 2017.

It was a reminder to leaders that "priorities lie in the protection of athletes," she added.

Semenya has embarked on a long legal marathon to contest the World Athletics rule.

The Lausanne-based Court of Arbitration for Sport ruled against her in 2019 and the decision was validated by the Swiss Federal Court in Lausanne in 2020.

It judged that a testosterone level comparable to that of men gave female athletes "an insurmountable advantage".

The ECHR said the Swiss court did not give the case a "rigorous judicial review that was commensurate with the seriousness of the personal rights at issue", and had therefore breached Semenya's right to a fair trial under the European Convention on Human Rights.

It ordered Switzerland to pay her 80,000 euros ($93,000) for expenses.

- 'Not far enough' -

A lower chamber at the ECHR in 2023 ruled that Semenya was the victim of discrimination by the Court of Arbitration for Sport -- even if it did not call into question the World Athletics rule, nor allow Semenya to return to competition without taking medication.

Swiss authorities, supported by World Athletics, appealed to the European court's 17-member Grand Chamber, leading to Thursday's ruling.

The Grand Chamber, however, said it could not rule on any discrimination as the alleged offence did not fall under Switzerland's jurisdiction.

Seema Patel, a sports law expert, said "the Grand Chamber didn't go far enough to recognise all violations in this case".

"But there is at least an alert to sport that convention rights must be respected," she said.

Antoine Duval, another legal scholar, said the ECHR had implied the World Athletics rule was disproportionate.

Its judgement "encourages intersex athletes affected by these rules to go before the Court of Arbitration for Sport and relaunch the debate", he said.

There are many types of "differences in sexual development", a group of rare conditions involving genes, hormones and reproductive organs.

Formerly known as intersexuality, they occur in approximately one in 1,000 to 4,500 births.

Semenya was born with the "46 XY" chromosome, rather than the XX chromosome most women have.

Before the 2009 world championships, where Semenya won the 800m gold aged just 18, she was forced to undergo gender testing. She was then put on medication to reduce testosterone levels.

But Semenya said she felt like a "human guinea pig" and vowed to never allow it again.

Testosterone is produced by men and women but men produce 20 times more of the sex hormone.

But how much the hormone boosts performance remains a matter of debate.

- 'Degrading' -

The International Olympic Committee is weighing reintroducing gender testing.

World Athletics and World Boxing have already adopted chromosomal testing -- generally a cheek swab to check for the Y chromosome.

World Aquatics in 2023 adopted a policy that foresees such testing.

Supporters say such screening simplifies access to women's competition, and UN rapporteur Reem Alsalem has said such tests are "reliable and non-invasive".

But Madeleine Pape, a sociologist of gender in sport, says there is a lack of research proving DSD athletes gain a "disproportionate advantage" over XX competitors.

Human Rights Watch has argued that World Athletics rule is "degrading and invasive", as well as "scientifically contested".

The gender debate reignited in June around Paris Olympic boxing champion Imane Khelif.

Donald Trump and Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling were among those who stoked a row over the Algerian's gender.

Y.Havel--TPP