The Prague Post - Cold War flashbacks in Russia-US talks in Geneva

EUR -
AED 4.32907
AFN 81.325265
ALL 96.646938
AMD 450.928259
ANG 2.110205
AOA 1080.794091
ARS 1737.42607
AUD 1.780998
AWG 1.657435
AZN 2.005441
BAM 1.948386
BBD 2.374973
BDT 143.508194
BGN 1.955808
BHD 0.44446
BIF 3468.089935
BMD 1.17862
BND 1.508168
BOB 8.148065
BRL 6.253407
BSD 1.179218
BTN 103.839319
BWP 16.774314
BYN 3.994617
BYR 23100.955898
BZD 2.371596
CAD 1.625524
CDF 3328.423579
CHF 0.93431
CLF 0.028709
CLP 1126.242468
CNY 8.383999
CNH 8.378587
COP 4589.84171
CRC 594.141735
CUC 1.17862
CUP 31.233435
CVE 110.642954
CZK 24.308865
DJF 209.464108
DKK 7.463937
DOP 73.369053
DZD 152.50103
EGP 56.799472
ERN 17.679303
ETB 168.775039
FJD 2.671971
FKP 0.862725
GBP 0.869757
GEL 3.184413
GGP 0.862725
GHS 14.461725
GIP 0.862725
GMD 87.218056
GNF 10208.02958
GTQ 9.032668
GYD 246.664549
HKD 9.167261
HNL 30.832735
HRK 7.532442
HTG 154.293548
HUF 389.311803
IDR 19537.397727
ILS 3.94262
IMP 0.862725
INR 103.962965
IQD 1543.992461
IRR 49575.716061
ISK 143.202562
JEP 0.862725
JMD 189.210032
JOD 0.83558
JPY 174.444015
KES 152.632113
KGS 103.070552
KHR 4722.730576
KMF 492.663421
KPW 1060.736762
KRW 1636.714441
KWD 0.359797
KYD 0.982669
KZT 637.955205
LAK 25511.234621
LBP 105545.438628
LKR 356.204596
LRD 210.089115
LSL 20.449312
LTL 3.480159
LVL 0.712935
LYD 6.358681
MAD 10.613501
MDL 19.497973
MGA 5262.539159
MKD 61.297794
MMK 2474.407304
MNT 4240.305235
MOP 9.446575
MRU 47.084836
MUR 53.344676
MVR 18.035563
MWK 2044.745504
MXN 21.649191
MYR 4.956109
MZN 75.307132
NAD 20.448931
NGN 1762.662059
NIO 43.279204
NOK 11.639741
NPR 166.142511
NZD 2.001551
OMR 0.453169
PAB 1.179223
PEN 4.106371
PGK 4.942004
PHP 67.432373
PKR 331.788231
PLN 4.260806
PYG 8396.122912
QAR 4.291061
RON 5.06928
RSD 117.121854
RUB 98.124754
RWF 1701.927567
SAR 4.42057
SBD 9.660984
SCR 17.940644
SDG 708.95334
SEK 11.019486
SGD 1.511105
SHP 0.92621
SLE 27.464721
SLL 24715.08058
SOS 673.608557
SRD 44.948451
STD 24395.058492
STN 24.721559
SVC 10.317914
SYP 15324.174222
SZL 20.449241
THB 37.59413
TJS 11.055075
TMT 4.125171
TND 3.404739
TOP 2.760447
TRY 48.797938
TTD 7.999594
TWD 35.506525
TZS 2917.084885
UAH 48.658374
UGX 4129.287531
USD 1.17862
UYU 47.160548
UZS 14555.95947
VES 192.637038
VND 31097.893948
VUV 139.650082
WST 3.1204
XAF 653.473223
XAG 0.028241
XAU 0.000324
XCD 3.18528
XCG 2.125222
XDR 0.813072
XOF 651.777548
XPF 119.331742
YER 282.220577
ZAR 20.441717
ZMK 10608.996666
ZMW 27.788497
ZWL 379.515223
  • CMSD

    0.0300

    24.55

    +0.12%

  • CMSC

    -0.0900

    24.33

    -0.37%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.83

    -0.14%

  • SCS

    0.2500

    16.98

    +1.47%

  • RBGPF

    -0.6700

    76.6

    -0.87%

  • BCC

    1.0600

    81.52

    +1.3%

  • NGG

    -1.1600

    69.99

    -1.66%

  • BCE

    -0.3900

    23.1

    -1.69%

  • GSK

    -0.0600

    40.3

    -0.15%

  • RIO

    -1.0100

    61.98

    -1.63%

  • AZN

    -0.6200

    77.07

    -0.8%

  • VOD

    -0.2300

    11.43

    -2.01%

  • RYCEF

    0.0700

    15.32

    +0.46%

  • RELX

    0.5200

    47.61

    +1.09%

  • BTI

    -1.1100

    54.92

    -2.02%

  • BP

    0.2600

    34.56

    +0.75%

Cold War flashbacks in Russia-US talks in Geneva
Cold War flashbacks in Russia-US talks in Geneva

Cold War flashbacks in Russia-US talks in Geneva

Geneva, the neutral turf that was once host to so much Cold War bargaining, is again welcoming Russian and US officials to discuss missiles, nuclear arms and spheres of influence on the eve of a possible conflagration.

Text size:

There is a heavy whiff of the 20th-century East-West power struggles in the Swiss capital, a flashback to the tense period between World War II and the Soviet Union's collapse in 1991, when the fate of the world often appeared to hang in the balance.

The two rival camps are beginning to openly make the comparison themselves, even if observers note significant differences.

"What we're having now we have is kind of a remake of the Cold War, Cold War 2.0," Dmitri Polyansky, the Russian deputy ambassador to the United Nations, said last month, putting the blame on the United States.

In Berlin, the city once split by a wall that became the emblem of the Cold War, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken warned Thursday that any Russian invasion of Ukraine, which Westerners fear could happen at any moment, would bring the world back to a time "when this continent, and this city, were divided in two... with the threat of all-out war hanging over everyone's heads."

- 'Brinkmanship' -

The similarities are striking.

Firstly, the geographical split is identical, with Moscow facing down the West.

Military, too, there is once again the risk that a local conflict fought by proxy forces could degenerate into a much larger and more direct confrontation of great powers.

And as in the heyday of the Cold War, the two powers have rallied their allies and defended their spheres of influence in a classic display of realpolitik bloc logic.

While the Americans suspect the Russians of wanting to use Belarus as a rear base for a potential offensive in Ukraine, NATO, the transatlantic alliance that the United States recently tried to redirect towards China, has rediscovered its raison d'être from the time of its founding in 1949, namely to defend non-Soviet Europe from a possible attack by Moscow.

Russian President Vladimir Putin, a former KGB officer, is practicing "Cold War-style brinksmanship, threats and intimidation intended to burnish Putin's image as a strongman," Sarah Kreps, a professor at Cornell University, told AFP.

From the location of the talks to the vocabulary used and the issues on the table, it all has a vintage feel as the two sides haggle over the deployment of missiles and troops at the gates of the opposing bloc.

- Less ideology -

However, John Bolton, who served as national security advisor to former US president Donald Trump, noted that the current face-off lacks the ideological ingredient of Communism versus liberal democracy that "shaped the Cold War."

"What we're looking at now is much more a kind of typical nineteenth-century power-politics confrontation, and I don't think it's infused by ideology,” he said.

"The immediate issue that we face is not just Ukraine, but is Putin's effort to either reassert Russian control over the former Soviet Union or at a very, very, very bare minimum, establish Russian hegemony over it,” he said.

For Bolton, the current crisis is the culmination of a long drift borne of the blindness of Western leaders and thinkers who were lulled in the 1990s by the illusion of a world without major conflict and did not see that Moscow had never really accepted the dissolution of its empire. That was something Putin referred to in 2005 as the "greatest disaster" of the last century.

"Putin is both patient and agile," said Bolton, adding that the process has "not not been exactly fast, but it's been consistent," referring to the Russian military intervention in Georgia in 2008 then the annexation of Ukrainian Crimea in 2014.

If crisis erupts today, it is also because the US has partly withdrawn from the world stage -- President Joe Biden has made it clear that he has no intention of directly involving the United States in a new conflict.

"Clearly in Putin's mind, Russia is destined to be a great power” Bolton said, and the Russian leader likely resents that Beijing has replaced it in the role of Washington's number one rival.

Cold War or not, the strategic stakes have hardly changed. At the time, "there were nuclear weapons -- a lot of them -- but deterrence worked. Neither side was going to provoke a nuclear war because no one would win that war," said Kreps.

"Very little about that dynamic has changed other than the individuals involved, but the most important thing -- the strategic calculus -- remains the same.”

She warned that "we will see these types of crises come and go," but in the future, as in the Cold War of the past, "deterrence will keep a lid on major escalatory action.”

S.Danek--TPP