The Prague Post - Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts

EUR -
AED 4.13539
AFN 79.077253
ALL 97.883054
AMD 438.2579
ANG 2.029206
AOA 1030.202225
ARS 1252.590819
AUD 1.757687
AWG 2.029442
AZN 1.918655
BAM 1.948797
BBD 2.27103
BDT 136.654416
BGN 1.957508
BHD 0.424377
BIF 3346.039989
BMD 1.125904
BND 1.458431
BOB 7.772175
BRL 6.393674
BSD 1.124803
BTN 96.23803
BWP 15.240978
BYN 3.680355
BYR 22067.72314
BZD 2.259292
CAD 1.566842
CDF 3236.974635
CHF 0.93503
CLF 0.027624
CLP 1060.050581
CNY 8.135052
CNH 8.157435
COP 4788.076674
CRC 571.668648
CUC 1.125904
CUP 29.836462
CVE 109.874575
CZK 24.942138
DJF 200.095782
DKK 7.461435
DOP 66.125033
DZD 149.776803
EGP 56.988774
ERN 16.888564
ETB 151.606286
FJD 2.556024
FKP 0.847579
GBP 0.848476
GEL 3.101872
GGP 0.847579
GHS 14.846848
GIP 0.847579
GMD 80.510617
GNF 9740.388762
GTQ 8.653328
GYD 235.336753
HKD 8.757199
HNL 29.22017
HRK 7.538155
HTG 147.173769
HUF 404.537957
IDR 18642.497256
ILS 4.017449
IMP 0.847579
INR 96.313958
IQD 1473.464231
IRR 47414.640099
ISK 146.704971
JEP 0.847579
JMD 178.508558
JOD 0.798717
JPY 163.499876
KES 145.376908
KGS 98.460454
KHR 4503.89597
KMF 488.084658
KPW 1013.507431
KRW 1576.412769
KWD 0.345338
KYD 0.937386
KZT 580.891037
LAK 24307.841061
LBP 100776.318901
LKR 336.532219
LRD 224.954648
LSL 20.465959
LTL 3.324503
LVL 0.681049
LYD 6.143171
MAD 10.390479
MDL 19.373299
MGA 5042.128219
MKD 61.597174
MMK 2364.11196
MNT 4025.438078
MOP 9.004444
MRU 44.583992
MUR 51.735564
MVR 17.349877
MWK 1950.499077
MXN 21.966426
MYR 4.865511
MZN 71.932179
NAD 20.465777
NGN 1812.288795
NIO 41.393282
NOK 11.68969
NPR 153.97676
NZD 1.909168
OMR 0.433475
PAB 1.124813
PEN 4.109932
PGK 4.667415
PHP 62.538332
PKR 316.554119
PLN 4.242688
PYG 8985.072682
QAR 4.100031
RON 5.11588
RSD 116.804948
RUB 94.297887
RWF 1609.60905
SAR 4.223073
SBD 9.402256
SCR 15.9726
SDG 676.106227
SEK 10.891502
SGD 1.461289
SHP 0.884784
SLE 25.592167
SLL 23609.630717
SOS 642.821524
SRD 40.821929
STD 23303.944615
SVC 9.842028
SYP 14641.901264
SZL 20.454499
THB 37.159384
TJS 11.614365
TMT 3.951924
TND 3.377997
TOP 2.636979
TRY 43.629065
TTD 7.63992
TWD 34.013006
TZS 3039.941319
UAH 46.741012
UGX 4119.398825
USD 1.125904
UYU 46.981388
UZS 14519.889563
VES 102.567867
VND 29228.474118
VUV 135.918371
WST 3.119423
XAF 653.619931
XAG 0.034578
XAU 0.000339
XCD 3.042813
XDR 0.80913
XOF 653.634393
XPF 119.331742
YER 275.282527
ZAR 20.460776
ZMK 10134.477454
ZMW 29.833197
ZWL 362.540707
  • CMSD

    -0.0800

    22.33

    -0.36%

  • CMSC

    -0.0500

    22.11

    -0.23%

  • NGG

    -2.3900

    70.18

    -3.41%

  • JRI

    -0.0760

    12.95

    -0.59%

  • BCC

    2.4800

    89.58

    +2.77%

  • BTI

    -1.1500

    43.3

    -2.66%

  • SCS

    0.5700

    10.48

    +5.44%

  • BP

    0.4600

    28.59

    +1.61%

  • GSK

    -0.3000

    36.87

    -0.81%

  • RIO

    -0.8400

    59.18

    -1.42%

  • RBGPF

    2.8600

    65.86

    +4.34%

  • RYCEF

    0.4300

    10.6

    +4.06%

  • BCE

    0.9800

    22.23

    +4.41%

  • AZN

    -2.7700

    67.3

    -4.12%

  • RELX

    -0.8100

    54.06

    -1.5%

  • VOD

    -0.1500

    9.25

    -1.62%

Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts
Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts / Photo: Genya SAVILOV - AFP/File

Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts

Ukraine is relying on the massive use of drones to compensate for an artillery shell shortage and undermine Russian military capabilities, but experts warned they cannot tip the balance.

Text size:

Both drones used for strikes hundreds of kilometres away and commercial drones are starting to dominate the battlefield.

In particular, so-called First Person View (FPV) drones allow their pilots to see live images of the ground as if they were on board and can locate enemy units and, if armed with explosives, attack them from within a few kilometres.

"At the moment in Ukraine, we are seeing the use of drones on an unimaginable scale, we are really talking about tens and hundreds of thousands of drones on the battlefield," Ulrike Franke, a researcher at the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR), told AFP.

In its 2024 budget Kyiv earmarked 1.15 billion euros ($1.25 billion) for drones, and President Volodymyr Zelensky announced that the country will produce "one million drones" this year, after setting up a specific drone branch in February.

Kyiv's direction comes as its supporters are trying to bolster Ukrainian stocks -- London is set to deliver more than 10,000 drones, of which one thousand are FPV drones, and Paris is preparing to order 2,000 kamikaze drones, some of which will be used in Ukraine.

Ukrainian officials estimate between 100,000 and 120,000 drones are needed monthly.

Whereas it needs 200,000 to 250,000 artillery shells per month for a major offensive or 75,000 to 90,000 to sustain the war defensively, according to an Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) review.

Western backers largely depend on US stocks to sustain defence, but Kyiv does not have enough ammunition to launch a major offensive next year, it added.

So "Ukraine can reduce its requirements for artillery ammunition by significantly increasing production of strike drones" continued Michael Kofman and Franz-Stefan Gady in the IISS review.

Drones are "capable of reproducing many of the functions of artillery and missiles at a fraction of the cost", agreed Mykola Bielieskov of the Atlantic Council.

A small commercial drone costs just a few hundred euros, whereas a simple anti-tank missile, artillery shell or remotely operated munition costs several thousands.

- "Not ideal" -

Ukrainian FPV drones are currently responsible for between 65 and 85 percent of the destruction of Russian positions, according to a French military source.

But Ulrike Franke warned: "They use drones because they can produce or buy them, but it is not ideal."

FPV drones have a small load capacity of just hundreds of grams of explosive and a few kilograms for the largest commercial drones.

"Even large numbers of small drones cannot match the potency of artillery fire," agreed Stacie Pettyjohn in a study by American security think-tank "CNAS".

Drones can supplement indirect fire weapons, but they are not substitutes, she added.

In September, the New York Times reported that less than a third of drone strikes hit their target, as the machines can easily be jammed or disrupted by electronic countermeasures.

Ukraine can no longer count on superiority in the field of drones.

In 2022 Ukraine had a "9-to-1 advantage" in commercial drones but this lead has now "essential disappeared", Pettyjohn added.

"While the Russian Ministry of Defence was slow to catch up, Russian troops had quickly realized the utility of commercial quadcopters and volunteer groups had emerged to provide frontline soldiers with drones and the necessary training."

Russia also relied heavily on FPV kamikaze drones to thwart Ukraine’s counter-offensive last summer.

For Pettyjohn, although drones offer new capabilities, they ultimately make it more difficult to "concentrate forces, achieve surprise, and conduct offensive operations" so they will not make "truly disruptive change".

burs-mra/tq/ico/spb/cw

I.Horak--TPP