UN climate negotiations at the Cop31 summit in Turkey entered a critical standstill on Saturday night as delegates struggled to resolve deep divisions over the inclusion of fossil fuel phaseout language and financial support for developing nations. The impasse has sparked fears that the conference may fail to reach a consensus, with Saudi Arabia and its allies firmly resisting explicit commitments to end the use of coal, oil, and gas.
UN climate negotiations at the Cop31 summit in Turkey entered a critical standstill on Saturday night as delegates struggled to resolve deep divisions over the inclusion of fossil fuel phaseout language and financial support for developing nations. The impasse has sparked fears that the conference may fail to reach a consensus, with Saudi Arabia and its allies firmly resisting explicit commitments to end the use of coal, oil, and gas.
The co-conveners of the summit, Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum, held extended meetings with scores of countries throughout Saturday in an attempt to break the deadlock. The fortnight-long talks have now overrun their scheduled timeline without resolution, leading to growing frustration among both participating nations and environmental campaigners.
The primary obstacles to a final agreement center on two contentious issues. A loose coalition of approximately 130 countries is insisting that the final outcome explicitly reference a "transition away from fossil fuels." This language was agreed upon at the previous summit in Dubai three years ago but has been repeatedly contested by Saudi Arabia and other oil-rich nations who oppose any explicit statement limiting fossil fuel use.
Simultaneously, developing countries are demanding stronger guarantees of financial support from wealthy nations to help them adapt to the escalating impacts of the climate crisis. The lack of progress on these fronts has led to a stalemate that threatens the viability of the entire conference.
A third draft of a potential headline agreement, released in the early hours of Sunday, attempted to navigate the impasse by recalling the deal reached in Dubai. This reference acknowledged the consensus on moving away from burning coal, oil, and gas but stopped short of introducing new binding mechanisms for phaseout.
Maina Talia, Tuvalu’s climate minister, emphasized the stakes for vulnerable nations. "This [inclusion of a reference to fossil fuels] is a red line for us," Talia said. "We’re talking about the root cause of all this. [Without it] we are wasting our time here."
Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa thinktank, expressed similar concerns regarding the broader failure of the summit to deliver on previous promises. "We came to Antalya needing progress on public climate finance, adaptation and fossil fuels," Adow said. "Instead, we are fighting to stop governments retreating from promises they have already made. Rich countries have spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver the [financial] support they promised. It feels like this meeting is unravelling."
Disagreements also persist over controversial technologies and targets. Saudi Arabia has pushed for strong recommendations regarding "carbon capture and storage" (CCS) in the final cover decision, a move opposed by other countries who view the technology as a means to perpetuate the fossil fuel industry. Additionally, there are conflicts over a target to derive 35% of the world’s energy from electricity by 2035.
The third draft of the cover decision attempted to address these tensions by removing a hard target for CCS and acknowledging that as much electrification as possible must be powered by clean energy. This text was scheduled for debate at a formal plenary session on Sunday morning.
Campaigners have placed blame for the lack of progress squarely on the fossil fuel industry and wealthy nations that have failed to deliver on financial pledges. Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, stated, "This must be the last time we allow fossil fuel interests, which are profiting so handsomely from the climate crisis, to hold us to ransom. It is abundantly clear by now that we will not be able to combat climate change as long as those who control the global economy can make money from coal, oil and gas."
Harjeet Singh, global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign, added, "You can’t ask developing countries to transform their economies while they’re drowning in disasters and debt. Whatever deal emerges in Antalya, the world should know why this Cop failed. It wasn’t a lack of solutions, it was a lack of money and a lack of will from those who caused this crisis."
The uncertainty surrounding the conclusion of the talks has led many delegates to reschedule their flights home. If enough participants leave, the conference may no longer meet the quorum required under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The resolution to include fossil fuel language was first agreed at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023. However, Saudi Arabia and its allies prevented further progress on implementation. At last year’s Cop30, Brazilian hosts attempted to bypass this obstruction by pledging to draft a global roadmap for phaseout. This year, the resolution appeared in a first draft of the agreed outcome but was excised from a revised draft published on Thursday.
The third draft acknowledged the issue obliquely through a reference recalling the "United Arab Emirates consensus" reached in Dubai. This inclusion followed a march to the presidency office by the EU, the UK, many African countries, and small island states demanding the reinstatement of the reference.
Claudio Angelo of Observatorio do Clima criticized the structure of the current summit, noting that the dual presidency—a compromise between Australia and Turkey—may be contributing to the difficulties. "It goes to show how a weak presidency, split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, can be detrimental to a process already victimised by geopolitics," Angelo said.
One possible next step under consideration is forcing an open meeting where Saudi Arabia and its allies would be required to publicly state their opposition to the stronger outcome desired by most other countries. This strategy carries the risk of collapsing the talks entirely.
Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics, offered a different perspective on the geopolitical dynamics. "If the overwhelming number of countries here want a strong text referencing the transition away from fossil fuels and so on and Saudi Arabia is on its own, I think Saudi Arabia will probably not stand against the global consensus," Hare said.
Reports indicate that China and India, while not part of the progressive coalition of 130 countries, are unlikely to oppose a deal. Miatta Fahnbulleh, the UK’s energy minister, maintained that negotiations remain productive. "We are working closely with partners to find a way through and secure an agreement that moves us forward," she said. "These are difficult negotiations, but discussions remain productive and there is a deal to be done."
As Sunday progresses, the international community watches closely to see if the stalled talks can be revived or if the summit will end without a binding agreement on the critical issue of fossil fuel phaseout.
S.Danek--TPP